Linux Mint surpasses MX Linux on Distrowatch to grab #1 spot

Yes, I know that the ranking is not a good metric of real world use.

Just posting this because MX Linux has been in the number one spot for a long time (2 years perhaps?) and it’s surprising to see some other distro on the top of their site.

https://distrowatch.com/

MX Linux, the king of asking ‘what’s Mx linux’ and inadvertently fueling its growth in distrowatch

Save me the trouble, what is it?

Just think of it as Ubuntu with wm and no bloat

It’s Debian with customizations, as well as some custom GUI programs for managing the system.

https://mxlinux.org/

Look it up on distrowatch

A Debian + Xfce (other DEs available) desktop distro with rather outdated looks.

I wonder how long it will take before it will drop off the top 10.

Somewhere between 10000 years and 5 minutes

Windows copy dialog be like.

Funny never heard of mx linux

No one has until they look at distro watch /j

You say that as a joke, but that is exactly how I figured out it exists.

I really don’t think the /j is necessary.

ive been into linux for a year and a half and ive never hears of MX linux until today

I’ve been into Linux for like twenty years and used probably ten or fifteen distros and never heard of it

It’s funny and awesome that the two top distro are Ubuntu remixes that remove snap.

Edit: I’m wrong. MX uses Debian as upstream, not Ubuntu, which removes any snap related tech from the picture entirely.

IMO Ubuntu without Snap, but with a default Gnome or KDE (and a visual DE selector screen during installation) would be absolutely perfect.

What? MX Linux is a Debian remix in the style of antiX I thought?

Shoot, you’re right. I thought MX used Ubuntu as upstream but it uses Debian.

I really like mint although i never used it again.
Pros using mint :

It’s easy to learn
It’s stable
It’s Windows XP like
Not recourse hogging like KDE
Easy to customize

Cons using mint :

It’s debian based

Not recourse hogging like KDE

KDE has been hogging no resources for ages now, it’s really snappy even on not so powerful machines!

How many fucking years will we be out of KDE 4 before these yahoos figure that out?

Yes, unless you install some buggy stuff on top it’s as snappy as xfce - tested on literally j4125 (it’s GPU helps), with wobbly burning windows and everything no holdups, smol RAM usage too (especially stock).

Cons: It’s not Debian

That’s what LMDE is for :)

That’s still not Debian ;)

Debian based is alright, I’m more against it for being based on Ubuntu. Also con: apt

Not recourse hogging like KDE

Really not that bad nowadays.

There is an official Debian-based edition of Mint: LMDE. It’s what I use.

yeah I run kde on my 12yo laptop and it’s smooth

New to Linux, why is Debian based considerd a con?

Very old packages.

They have security updates, but are usually held back years to ensure stability.

And that’s a problem if stability is not one of your biggest priorities.

Why is Debian based a problem? I ask this as my first IRL Linux user that taught me about Linux still uses Debian Unstable as his daily driver workhorse, and he is a CS Theory Doctor, and has to reboot his system once a year or so to keep it functioning properly.

Cinnamon is way more resource hogging than KDE.

They are about the same

You know what? You might be right; I never actually bothered to check if Cinnamon was heavier than Plasma, I just remember it feeling very stuttery when I last daily drove it. Admittedly, that was a very long time ago and GNOME was a complete shit show back then so Cinnamon probably just inherited some of its performance issues. I imagine all of that is fixed by now.

Debian based is very much not a con. You want a working stable system that is easy to use. RHEL like systems can be more stable but the added overhead means a slower package manager

I really don’t like Mint. It feels like a discount version of Debian/Ubuntu to me. It makes it even worse that the person who introduced it to me has all the worst toxic traits. Now I can’t see it as a good alternative.

It might just be a matter of perspective. I’m not very knowledgeable on distros, so my opinion may come from ignorance:

To me, Ubuntu is too resource intensive with too much going on. Mint seems relatively lean yet modern, with all the basics covered. Debian is a little sparse (no sudo, no fdisk, what’s going on here?).

Who told you you can’t sudo on Debian? ^^ I feel like Debian is flexible enough to give you the system you might want without the bullshit. Ubuntu has lost its way last decade, but you can still debloat it mostly and use one of its alternatives. The Cinnamon DE has improved a lot, but it still feels like Windows Vista to me.

I ended up using NixOS lately so I can have the flexibility, newer packages and very clean repeatable configuration.

I haven’t seen sudo installed by default on debian. Probably the comment is about that. When you start you tend to use only what is already there to not mess things too much.

Kubuntu is where it’s at.

Everyone forgets Xubuntu 🫠

Wait until you find out about package managers

It’s Ubuntu without Snaps and a nice DE.

Ignore people when it comes to software. Many advocate Mint. Some are lovely, some are dicks. That goes for every distro.

I’ve never understood the Mint hype. Like you say it seems like Ubuntu with extra steps.

I do have beefs with some of the decisions Canonical makes but if anyone asks me what distri they should start with I will always recommend Ubuntu simply because it’s “the distro” if you search for “Linux” tutorials online 9 times out of 10 you will get a tutorial aimed at Ubuntu. Packages for software that isn’t in repos are usually available as .deb …

It’s not really a hype. It just vibes with a lot of people.

Someone doesn’t like windows because they put ads in their start menu: aww you’re sweet

Someone doesn’t like Ubuntu because they put ads in their start menu: hello, human resources?

Ubuntu is buggy and broken due to the system design

It was good 15 years ago…

Welcome to c/linux!

Welcome to our thriving Linux community! Whether you’re a seasoned Linux enthusiast or just starting your journey, we’re excited to have you here. Explore, learn, and collaborate with like-minded individuals who share a passion for open-source software and the endless possibilities it offers. Together, let’s dive into the world of Linux and embrace the power of freedom, customization, and innovation. Enjoy your stay and feel free to join the vibrant discussions that await you!

Rules:

Stay on topic: Posts and discussions should be related to Linux, open source software, and related technologies.
Be respectful: Treat fellow community members with respect and courtesy.
Quality over quantity: Share informative and thought-provoking content.
No spam or self-promotion: Avoid excessive self-promotion or spamming.
No NSFW adult content
Follow general lemmy guidelines.

Linux Mint surpasses MX Linux on Distrowatch to grab #1 spot(lemmy.world)

Linux

!linux@lemmy.world

Community stats

Community moderators