5 points

Murder?

I think not. Murder is a crime. And it’s bad. (crime doesn’t necessarily mean bad, see Robin Hood for more details)

Nazis don’t count, all you’re doing is cleaning up the trash.

You can’t murder a nazi. You can certainly kill them though.

It’s an important distinction, in my opinion.

permalink
report
reply
9 points

Why can i not murder a nazi? A murder is the deliberate ending of someone’s life. Why is that not applicable to Nazis?

permalink
report
parent
reply
3 points

Murder is a crime. And it’s bad. (crime doesn’t necessarily mean bad, see Robin Hood for more details)

Nazis don’t count, all you’re doing is cleaning up the trash.

permalink
report
parent
reply
3 points
*

"> Murder is a crime. And it’s bad. (crime doesn’t necessarily mean bad, see Adolf Hitler for more details)

Jews don’t count, all you’re doing is cleaning up the trash."

🤔

permalink
report
parent
reply
13 points
*

Justifying the murder of someone by dehumanizing them is exactly what the nazis did. It’s what Israel is doing in Gaza, etc., calling everyone Hamas and dehumanizing them. Nazis may be terrible people who need to be fought against and whose ideology needs to be stopped, but it’s never good to start dehumanizing groups of people over any criteria. All that said I love playing Wolfenstein and Indiana Jones games and killing hordes of nazis.

permalink
report
parent
reply
12 points

The scariest thing about Nazis is that they’re human and even pretty smart sometimes. To reiterate what others are saying: dehumanization leaves you in a blind spot for the humans around you who can silently undergo vast transformations from people you thought you loved into Nazis. They throw away their humanity yes, but they had to be human to throw it away. Dehumanization is also how the process of becoming a Nazi starts. Don’t even mirror it in jest, try on radical empathy and face the truth: humans are horrifically complex. Nazis are unfortunately humans.

permalink
report
parent
reply
1 point

Nazis are incredibly mechanical honestly. They lose empathy and then others become mearly disposable objects. You might commit murder just like you would throw away a plastic bag. There is a totally absence of care which leads you to inflict terrible things to others.

I also doubt how many actual Nazis there are. It is often thrown around which leads it to lose the horrible meaning. I’ve seen people shout Nazis over much less deadly things. Don’t confuse systematic mass murder with someone having a questionable character. They can be a terrible human but they haven’t committed the level of crimes as mass murder of millions. The level of death and suffering caused by the holocaust is not a joke and certainty not something to use when your upset.

Sorry for the rant I just needed to get that off my chest. I’m not really addressing anyone in particular.

permalink
report
parent
reply
93 points

“Bethesda covers its arse in anticipation of a bunch of terminally online American teenagers who just learnt the word ‘nazi’ and would use it to describe a fuckin nun if it made them feel a bit morally superior for ten seconds”

permalink
report
reply
82 points

I’ve heard plenty of people try to say WOLFENSTEIN glorifies nazis

I’ve had one idiot tell me ANY media that paints them as competent or successful is glorifying them. And setting anything in a world where they succeeded and progressed technologically instead of collapsing is basically saying Hitler’s world view is valid.

I still don’t know how to respond to that beyond “if you think the nazis were incompetent you don’t know history, and if you think showing a future where fascism took hold is unrealistic I have some bad news for you”

It’s fantasy, and specifically a fantasy in which you get to go on a massive killing spree against some of the worst people in history, how you can somehow pull “this game is making these guys look good” from that, I’m not sure.

permalink
report
parent
reply
5 points

If they didn’t have at least a few competent nazis, they wouldn’t have been such a threat; WW2 would be over in a month. I’m sure there were even competent Talibans and North Koreans.

permalink
report
parent
reply
6 points

Here’s my problem with wolfenstein. The daat yichud or whatever was a little too close to the secret Jewish cabal that real life Hitler believed/claimed was working behind the scenes manipulating society for is own gains. I don’t think the series is pro Nazi, I’d have to be stupid to believe that, but I feel this particular plot point was a little tone deaf in a historical context.

permalink
report
parent
reply
8 points
*
Removed by mod
permalink
report
parent
reply
7 points

How exactly does he think…

checks list

…a whole shitload of things exist? Everything from microwave ovens, to nasa space rockets, to jet engines? Shit! If the nazis weren’t so god damned evil they would have been pretty awesome…but they aren’t. You know, because of the whole evil facist racists thing.

But damn they knew how to invent stuff, and have stylish military uniforms while doing so.

permalink
report
parent
reply
28 points

It should be noted that a lot of their blunders later in the war can be traced back to Hitler (or one of his sycophants) getting involved and overruling far more experienced Generals, many of whom were not party members. It could also be argued that the economy they set up, while impressive given the state of Germany post-WWI, was an entirely unsustainable war economy that relied very heavily on slave labor. That’s not to say they were completely incompetent, but they did vastly overestimate their own abilities and made many mistakes as a result.

permalink
report
parent
reply
8 points

Indeed, they made plenty of mistakes, otherwise they would have won the war.

But it’s less about whether they could have sustained their empire afterward and more people trying to say that portraying them as such is “glorifying” them or propping them up in some sort of idealistic way.

permalink
report
parent
reply
9 points
*

It’s worse than that. Hitler’s entire economic plan relied on heavily burrowing money from other countries with the intent to pay it back with money plundered from conquered nations.

As for the people having better lives, well, not really. Earnings increased for workers but mainly from working even longer hours. The actual hourly wage fell on the level of the Great Depression. And due to less imported goods, consumer products like food and clothing also had to be rationed.

Who was better off by a lot however were large cartels and monopolies crushing small businesses thanks to the eridications of unions and, later, forced labor in the concentration camps.

So, while the (war) economy did boom, that didn’t really translate to better lives for common people (even before the war started).

permalink
report
parent
reply
4 points

Maybe it’s a skill issue. They never could make it past level one so the nazis are programmed to be too good!

permalink
report
parent
reply
11 points

I’ve had one idiot tell me ANY media that paints them as competent or successful is glorifying them. And setting anything in a world where they succeeded and progressed technologically instead of collapsing is basically saying Hitler’s world view is valid.

And people still wonder why I pick so much on the wishful thinking fallacy… I mean, that’s basically it, right? “Nazi are morally bad, I hate them, thus they must be incompetent”. And if you correctly highlight that this is fucking stupid, you’ll get some kid saying stuff like “I dun understand, why are you defending Nazi?”.

permalink
report
parent
reply
2 points
*

You’re misunderstanding the argument, but that’s just the nature of brief forum exchanges.

Think of it as a continuous depiction of the Nazis as hyper-competent or full of geniuses unintentionally playing into the supremacy narrative, even when Joe Everyman is gunning them down. I don’t agree that Wolfenstein is pro-Nazi but it is a factor in public perception that creators need to consider when repeated in a hundred different games or movies.

Even just repeating things like “At least Mussolini made the trains run on time” plays into it, especially when it’s a lie, just like the Wunderwaffe programs or the Nazi “miraculous economic recovery” which was just making people work longer hours and deficit spending.

permalink
report
parent
reply
4 points

If they think that, they may have a problem with what they consider glorified. They may want to avoid recognizing parallels that are far more personal to them.

permalink
report
parent
reply
12 points

I take your point but I wouldn’t class nuns as the ideal opposing example to Nazis, either.

EDIT: And yes, I know I’m doing the thing.

permalink
report
parent
reply
5 points

He’s fine with nazi dogs though…

permalink
report
reply
1 point

Off with his head!

permalink
report
parent
reply
10 points

“Who’s a victim of moral luck? Who’s a coerced actor? Is it you? It is! It is you!”

permalink
report
parent
reply
26 points

No way…what about wolfenstein??

permalink
report
reply
6 points

Whaaa Don’t you remember the scene where they said nazi made things better? /s https://youtu.be/3tJRVRx66GI?sT6VlEsv8uESpiuK

permalink
report
parent
reply
5 points

Damn I gotta play that one it looks fucking dope

permalink
report
parent
reply
2 points

It’s worth it for the story alone (both main games since the reboot). Such a wild collection of outrageous twists and turns, but with characters that you actually care about. They managed to write a main protagonist who - in between eviscerating Nazi mechas and blowing up secret bases while using improbable tech - is actually an emotionally vulnerable human being. This is such a stroke of genius that suddenly makes the entire scenario so much more believable and the story so much more impactful, because he and many of the other characters feel like real human beings, despite the almost exuberant embracing of clichés (only to then tear them up). It’s still campy as all hell, but it somehow works. I don’t think I’ve ever seen games juggle so many different balls without dropping any of them. Even if you don’t care about any of that, the shooting alone is second only to the recent DOOM reboots.

permalink
report
parent
reply
3 points

I randomly played the first cause it was on psplus and I got hooked. I really liked this new series and want more

permalink
report
parent
reply
5 points

Heavily censored in Germany apparently, which kinda seems odd and protective of Nazis

permalink
report
parent
reply
5 points

Yeah they have a blanket ban on Nazi iconography with no carve outs for art, even if antifascist.

permalink
report
parent
reply
0 points

That statement is not true and it never was.

permalink
report
parent
reply
7 points
*

Almost correct, but artistic depictions of Nazi iconography actually are exempt from the ban (falling under “Kunstfreiheit” - artistic freedom).

The reason why Wolfenstein still had to be censored was because video games were not really seen as a form of art for quite a long time. But AFAIK that has fortunately changed in the last years and you can now legally obtain uncensored Wolfenstein versions in Germany.

permalink
report
parent
reply
3 points

Wonder if that’s harmful in the long run, cause you’re not allowed to make the bad guys look like what they were, bad guys.

permalink
report
parent
reply
4 points

Germany be like, “Nazi symbols, NEIN!”, showing it is totally not missing the point, specially given whom they support.

permalink
report
reply
1 point

Don’t tell them about speeding

permalink
report
parent
reply
2 points

What

permalink
report
parent
reply
3 points

There are no more restrictions on Nazi symbols in videogames, except that glorifying Nazism remains illegal regardless of the medium, of course.

permalink
report
parent
reply

Gaming

!gaming@lemmy.zip

Create post

The Lemmy.zip Gaming Community

For news, discussions and memes!


Community Rules

This community follows the Lemmy.zip Instance rules, with the inclusion of the following rule:

  • No NSFW content

You can see Lemmy.zip’s rules by going to our Code of Conduct.

What to Expect in Our Code of Conduct:

  • Respectful Communication: We strive for positive, constructive dialogue and encourage all members to engage with one another in a courteous and understanding manner.
  • Inclusivity: Embracing diversity is at the core of our community. We welcome members from all walks of life and expect interactions to be conducted without discrimination.
  • Privacy: Your privacy is paramount. Please respect the privacy of others just as you expect yours to be treated. Personal information should never be shared without consent.
  • Integrity: We believe in the integrity of speech and action. As such, honesty is expected, and deceptive practices are strictly prohibited.
  • Collaboration: Whether you’re here to learn, teach, or simply engage in discussion, collaboration is key. Support your fellow members and contribute positively to shared learning and growth.

If you enjoy reading legal stuff, you can check it all out at legal.lemmy.zip.


Community stats

  • 2K

    Monthly active users

  • 2.6K

    Posts

  • 3.6K

    Comments