Hello my friends, the day is once more / Just wait to see what we have in store / A silly knife no doubt, and one that is furthermoreā€¦

ā€¦Naughty.

I have on multiple occasions mentioned owning several knives with various aspects that the law finds it within itself to frown upon. And probably just as often, expressed my own personal conclusion that regulations outlawing this feature or that particular mechanism or the other shape or whatever are ultimately all very silly when viewed from the perspective of anyone familiar with, you know, reality. Byzantine knife laws make the least sense out of pretty much anything because at the end of the day blade is a blade, and there is self-evidently no such thing, for example, as a ā€œhigh capacity assault knife.ā€ You could cut someone just as well with a 4" paring knife from the Dollar General as you could with the latest tactical spring loaded all black half serrated tanto point karambit switchblade from 5.11 or Emerson. Or a chunk of obsidian youā€™ve knapped on a rock, for that matter. One sharpened chunk of metal is much the same as any other from the standpoint of someone wanting to perform mischief with it ā€“ or one having mischief performed upon them with it.

(And thatā€™s notwithstanding the racist motivations that underpin specifically the US federal switchblade ban, balisong bans, and ā€œdirk and daggerā€ laws.)

But this. This is easily the single most likely thing Iā€™ve got liable to keep a harebrained legislator up at nights worrying.

Iā€™ve probably had it for about 20 years, and Iā€™m pretty sure I bought it from BudK back in the day, when I was in one of my ā€œget it before itā€™s bannedā€ moods.

Yes, this is a punch or push dagger. It is an early example of a brandless OEM Chinese special, so it never to my knowledge had any name or formal model designation, and while I canā€™t find its exact ilk for sale anymore you can still find things online rather like it. If you prefer a brand name option, the Cold Steel FGX Push Blade leaps to mind. It has very little utilitarian purpose. This blade, it is made for stabbinā€™.

Itā€™s also made entirely of G-10, and is therefore completely nonmetallic.

In last weekā€™s column I gave an overview of a ceramic bladed folding knife, which doesnā€™t have a metallic blade. But it still had a metallic liner, clip, and screws and therefore would not pass through a metal detector. This doesnā€™t, and it absolutely would.

But even still, donā€™t try it.

This ā€œknifeā€ is a 5" long, 0.175" thick, single flat piece of textured G-10, which has a cord wrapped T handle and a flat ground ā€œbladeā€ profile milled into it. For its part, G-10 is extremely strong for its weight (in total here only 17.4 grams or 0.62 ounces) and also surprisingly rigid. But considering that the thing and the whole of the thing is just fiberglass suspended in an epoxy resin, it doesnā€™t actually hold an edge worth a damn. Like, at all.

So while there is an edge bevel on it, itā€™s not even sharp enough to make a reliable letter opener. Even if you carefully sharpened it, itā€™s unlikely it would last for more than one cut. The material is just too soft and prone to abrasion.

But thatā€™s not the point. The point is the point, and this knife is probably quite stout enough to Render Unto Caesar that what is Caesarā€™s. Maybe not all 23 times, but certainly at least once. As a last-ditch holdout, it would seriously inconvenience anyone you punched with it although I imagine given how soft the material is it would utterly fail to penetrate leather or even the cheapest soft body armor.

Even so, I would not want to have this coming at me unexpectedly in the dark.

I present this to you bare, because although it did arrive with a belt sheath ā€“ which ironically contained a large steel button snap on it, completely defeating its implied purpose ā€“ this was made of fake leather so abysmal that it literally disintegrated into fish flakes while in storage in my knife cabinet. So I threw it away. Maybe some day Iā€™ll 3D print a replacement one, or something.

Whatevs. Iā€™m obviously not carrying this thing with me anywhere, so I canā€™t think of a single thing thatā€™s a lower priority.

The Inevitable Conclusion

Itā€™s probably because of things like this that all of our airports have switched over from plain metal detectors to those backscatter X-ray machines now.

Itā€™s all theater, though. Both that and this. Despite what the hysterical shriekers would have you believe if they could, to the nearest couple of decimal points no one is actually smuggling these anywhere, nor are they the crux of any kind of secret terrorist plot, and while weā€™re at it nor is anyone realistically going to successfully use it as a last-ditch self defense tool when so many other ones are both better and just as readily available.

Even so, itā€™s sometimes nice to know that just by owning something like this youā€™re pissing off the right people, even if only passively.

8 points

This thing looks like everybodyā€™s first 3d print

permalink
report
reply
4 points

ā€¦how did you make me read the opening in Fredā€™s voice.

permalink
report
reply
4 points

Well written as usual!

permalink
report
reply
4 points

I love your writing!

permalink
report
reply
3 points

A knife is a poor self defense weapon because, even with ample training and practice, if you pull it youā€™re going to get cut.

The KA-BAR TDI design attempts to mitigate the risk. Itā€™s a last ditch weapon, worn on your weak side assuming your strong side and primary weapon are tied up.

permalink
report
reply

Itā€™s even worse with the original sheath design, which was a low-rise belt loop with a full width, fold-over button snap retention flap. There was no way to draw it quickly.

This ā€œknifeā€ has no real purpose other than novelty, Iā€™m sure.

permalink
report
parent
reply
3 points

Totally mall ninja. You probably know more about all this than I do. But, grab a TDI if you donā€™t have one already. Iā€™m pretty impressed with why they designed it the way they did and how solid it is for the price.

permalink
report
parent
reply

PocketKNIFE

!pocketknife@lemmy.world

Create post

This is the place for talking about all things pocket knives, and knife adjacent things. Folders large and small, multi-tools, sharpeners, even fixed blade knives are welcome. Reviews! Advice! Show off your Knives!

Also home of the incredibly loquacious Weird Knife Wednesday feature.

Simple Rules

  • Donā€™t be an asshole.
  • Post any bigotry or hate speech and weā€™ll cut you.
  • No gore or injury posts.
  • Keep politics out of here, unless itā€™s knife related.
  • Brand/model/maker/etc. elitism is highly frowned upon.
  • Shilling your brand or product is OK provided thatā€™s not all you do and you make other contributions.
  • For sale and trade posts allowed, but site admins and mods are not responsible for the outcome.

Community stats

  • 187

    Monthly active users

  • 76

    Posts

  • 179

    Comments