You are viewing a single thread.
View all comments
3 points

Man, I say this a lot and I know it comes across standoffish, but… US ethnic categorizations seem bonkers to me.

What does “half Jewish half Irish” even mean? Isn’t that a Jewish person from Ireland? That would count as fully both things. What are the other two halves?

This is why I have to think about the immigration form for ten minutes each time I get through customs in the US, it’s all “was any of your grandparents a smurf?” and “are you latino and/or lactose intolerant?” and stuff like that. It makes no sense.

permalink
report
reply
1 point

Is it just the Jewish part that you don’t get? The US has so many different active cultures going on in the same spaces that knowing someone’s ethnic background can tell you a lot about them and their family. I’m sure some people want to know because they’re racist, but for most people it’s just a cultural shorthand. Knowing someone is Cuban rather than Puerto Rican, or half Spanish and half Irish tells you what kinds of experiences they might have had, what comfort foods they’re likely to eat, how they’re likely to celebrate their holidays. Stuff like that. Especially if one of their cultural identities is one that you share, or frequently share the same spaces with, you’ve probably just found a whole lot of commonalities with that person. Older people might ask. In my experience younger people generally won’t. So either it’s obvious to you or they tell you or you might not know at all.

From a governmental standpoint, they keep track of different statistics based on ethnicity, supposedly so they can make sure they’re not failing any groups of people with representation, healthcare outcomes, policing, etc. It obviously doesn’t always work, but that’s supposed to be why the government is interested.

permalink
report
parent
reply
1 point

Aw, you guys are gonna make me answer this seriously, aren’t you?

No, it’s not the Jewish part that I don’t get. I have been around enough to understand that Wilson is implying that she has some (presumably) Ashkenazi and some Irish ancestry, and I am self-aware enough to understand that she would sound insane if she put it that way.

The fact that she’s calling it out as a shorthand for common cultural ground is the part that is strange, let alone the persistent hangup with ancestry and the weird assumption that culture is somehow genetic. I was just trying to break it down gently by being facetious about it.

It’s weird, it’s highly specific to American culture, and yes, I do get the very deep roots in colonialism that lead to this outcome. It’s just weird to me that’s where it landed and how often Americans seem to think it’s universal when it’s actually pretty unusual.

I was not kidding about the census categorizations that get repurposed on immigration forms, though. They are full of apples and oranges in all sorts of arrangements and I have never once felt I fit on any of the categories or that the categories themselves make any sense.

permalink
report
parent
reply
2 points

the weird assumption that culture is somehow genetic

Do you think parents’ ancestry plays zero part in a child’s cultural experience in the US? Like as soon as you’re born on US soil you’re only allowed to eat KFC and burgers, and you can never hear folktales and history from a different country. Not to mention how cultural heritage plays into how you are perceived.

There’s a difference between people saying “my great granddad was irish so I’m basically from Ireland and st paddy’s day is the greatest holiday woooo!” and a Japanese American kid getting teased in elementary school for a foreign sounding name and eating pickled plums during lunch, or a Jewish kid in predominantly Christian areas never having their cultural holidays off school and feeling left out.

permalink
report
parent
reply
1 point

Part of the reason she’s bothering to be that specific is for the “dammit ratcliffe” joke, it would be unnoteworthy except in a a”genetically predisposed to” context otherwise, but by being unnecessarily specific the cumulative effect of the joke gives a bigger payoff.

Essentially the “two nickels” joke but she’s allergic to nickel

permalink
report
parent
reply
0 points

I really appreciate the child of colonizers telling the children of immigrants how they should act.

Bang up job.

permalink
report
parent
reply
0 points

Right… because I’ve never met a European who verbalized their white ethnic backgrounds before.

permalink
report
parent
reply
1 point

How difficult is this concept?

Mother from Ireland Father from Israel, ethnically Jewish

50/50 ignoring realistic genetic history.

permalink
report
parent
reply
1 point

I’ve never heard one say “I’m half English” either.

Personally it just seems a way to label people to let them know they’re not proper Americans.

permalink
report
parent
reply
1 point

Americans are all about ethnicities like that, such as “I’m half Polish and half German on my mother’s side” or “my family is Italian” though technically they’re from Long Island or Wisconsin or something. Almost nobody describes their heritage as just “American”.

permalink
report
parent
reply
1 point
*

People can be ethnically Jewish or religiously Jewish and they are separate identities. Historically, religiously jewish people tended to only marry other religiously jewish people, leading to the formation of a jewish ethnicity over time. For many, these identities are closely intertwined, for others they have both but view them separately. And for many others still, they only fit into one category or the other.

Irish, in contrast, is only an ethnicity but not a religion. (Unless you count certain sects of Celtic Paganism, but that’s usually not what people mean)

If one parent is predominantly of Jewish heritage and the other of Irish heritage, then their child might identify as half-jewish-half-irish.

Genetically speaking, they are likely less than 50% of each because that would imply that each parent was completely and totally 100% their respective ethnicity genetically, which is (if possible) very very unlikely and realistically not 100% strictly defined.

People like to categorize things, including categories. For some, a part of their identity is based on the ethnic categories they fit themselves into, and some group these categories under one subsection of their identity, and assign weights to the different components of that category.

I love the funny things our pattern seeking brains do in order to quantify the unquantifiable and to better establish a sense of belonging and self in this amorphous and crazy society we’re all a part of. What’s really great is that none of what I’ve said is even universally true. It’s just (from my observation) the most common way I’ve seen all these categories combined. If you disagree, you’re completely free to do so, and neither of us are wrong until we start using numbers and statistics in our argument

permalink
report
parent
reply
0 points

I think the confusing part is that Jewish is considered by most people to be both a religion and an ethnicity.

permalink
report
parent
reply
0 points

Yeah I’m still not sure about that.

I think it’s an ethnic group with a religion and sometimes a non ethnic person join them?

permalink
report
parent
reply
1 point

It’s an ethnic group and a religion. The vast majority of the religious group is from the ethnic group because they usually don’t try to convert people. Her note about being secular indicates she is part of the ethnic group but not part of the relegious group.

permalink
report
parent
reply
0 points

What does “half Jewish half Irish” even mean?

One parent is Irish and the other is Jewish.

permalink
report
parent
reply
2 points

So what are the religion and nationality of the other parents and why don’t they count?

permalink
report
parent
reply
1 point

Jewish is also an ethnicity. That’s why they can be ‘secular’ while still being half Jewish.

permalink
report
parent
reply
1 point

In this context Jewish is the ethnicity, Mara actually calls it out in the tweet

permalink
report
parent
reply
1 point

Or one parent was Irish and Jewish and the other was french and atheist

permalink
report
parent
reply
0 points

You can be raised by one Jewish parent and one Other parent and still not be a follower of Judaism. You might still have a Jewish cultural heritage and place in the world despite differing theological views.

permalink
report
parent
reply
0 points

If it’s the mother then they are Jewish, if it’s the father they are not

permalink
report
parent
reply
1 point
*

I didn’t know the genes for Judaism were located in the X chromosome.

permalink
report
parent
reply

People Twitter

!whitepeopletwitter@sh.itjust.works

Create post

People tweeting stuff. We allow tweets from anyone.

RULES:

  1. Mark NSFW content.
  2. No doxxing people.
  3. Must be a tweet or similar
  4. No bullying or international politcs
  5. Be excellent to each other.

Community stats

  • 9.5K

    Monthly active users

  • 710

    Posts

  • 16K

    Comments