feddit.org

-3 points

2 months ago

I didn’t say you did. Would you like me to start calling you a liar about things you haven’t said? Because that’s kinda your whole thing. Well, your whole thing when you’re talking to people who aren’t 100% in favor of genocide.

report

[ - ]

BassTurd@lemmy.world

1 point

2 months ago

Your comments were directed at me, clearly. If you can point to any times that I claimed something not true, you can certainly call me a liar. Instead, you keep claiming falsehoods about people supporting genocide. I have seen exactly 0 comments that are pro genocide. You are making claims that are verifiably false. That’s why I’m calling you a liar, because you have made no factual statements.

report

[ - ]

-3 points

2 months ago

Your comments were directed at me, clearly.

Persecution complex much?

I was referring to the people on this thread who accuse genocide opponents of being trump supporters. If that’s you, it wouldn’t surprise me, but I wasn’t referring to you.

I have seen exactly 0 comments that are pro genocide.

Here’s one:

The number of “left” voters in this community that are doing their damnedest to get Trump elected never ceases to disturb me.

It’s accusing anyone who has any objections to the genocide of being Trump supporters pretending to be leftists. You don’t have to feign illiteracy whenever someone you agree with says the only part out loud.

report

[ - ]

BassTurd@lemmy.world

3 points

2 months ago

“I trust that you’ll also be calling all the people who accuse anyone who is even slightly unhappy about genocide of being trump supporters liars too, *right*?”

That was a reply from you to me. It’s not a persecution complex when you literally did that I said you did.

Where in your example of a pro genocide comment, does it suggest that anyone against genocide is a Trump supporter? Nowhere, because it didn’t happen. You are just making up more shit.

report

[ - ]

-1 points

2 months ago

That was a reply from you to me. It’s not a persecution complex when you literally did that I said you did.

You called me a liar. You didn’t call the “you don’t support genocide so you’re a trumpist” people liars.

Where in your example of a pro genocide comment, does it suggest that anyone against genocide is a Trump supporter?

You’re pretending it isn’t what they said? Gaslight someone else.

Do you believe that genocide is wrong? I have to ask because I haven’t seen any indication at all that you do, and you’ve made it clear that you really don’t like it when centrists are called out on the only argument they have for their continued support for genocide.

report

[ - ]

BassTurd@lemmy.world

0 points

2 months ago

I think genocide is bad. I think Israel is committing genocide against Palestine. It’s absolutely disgusting and I would love if the USA could/would somehow cut the cord on support until they stop permanently. I say “could” because when talking about geopolitics, the world is extremely complicated, and I know that I, and probably every person here, don’t know everything the US government does regarding relations with Israel and the implications of cutting off support. I’m not putting on a tin foil hat or anything, I just know that I don’t know everything, so it would be disingenuous to say that it’s as easy as just saying no to Israel.

The problem I have, is that comments like yours saying that Harris is 100% pro genocide, which is an emotionally charged statement to complex situation. Those types of comments infer information, pass it as facts, and then use that to attack her. I don’t think there is anything wrong with being critical of the situation, and i believe discourse is healthy for growth and betterment, but these are just brute force attacks that don’t help the situation. They don’t leave room for an open dialogue, and are more likely to hurt Harris’s chances of winning in November. I do believe that at the root of of these statements, the intent is to pressure the admin for change, but I think that it has the adverse effect due to the way the argument is presented, especially because currently as VP, she doesn’t have the power to change anything anyway.

I feel like a broken record saying this in Lemmy, but when November comes, there will be two candidates with a chance to be POTUS. Until then, Harris’s #1 goal is to get elected, because if that doesn’t happen then she can’t do anything anyways. Attacking that and turning off voters can end the most important part of change. After the election is complete and if she wins, go to town on the hard protesting when she actually can enact change and Trump is no longer a legitimate threat to the future of the US and likely a much worse situation for Palestine.

To reiterate, I hope Netanyahu faces punishment for the atrocities that he has ordered. I hope that there is a Nuremberg Trials type situation once all of this is resolved, and that people face consequence. I hope that I’m wrong and it’s super easy, and that Harris sees the light and says “no”.

report

[ - ]

-1 points

2 months ago

The problem I have, is that comments like yours saying that Harris is 100% pro genocide

I never said that, but you have no issue at all with lying, do you? Just when you take personal offense on behalf of genocide supporters.

I don’t think there is anything wrong with being critical of the situation

Coulda fooled me.

I do believe that at the root of of these statements, the intent is to pressure the admin for change, but I think that it has the adverse effect due to the way the argument is presented, especially because currently as VP, she doesn’t have the power to change anything anyway.

That doesn’t mean there can’t be daylight between her and Biden. She’s not the Secretary of State. She can differ from the president on foreign policy.

After the election is complete and if she wins, go to town on the hard protesting

You’ll find some other excuse to demand silence about genocide at that point.

If you really thing genocide is wrong, you should say something without prompting instead of demanding silence on the flimsy notion that griping about genocide on a tiny fledgling platform is somehow going to make all the dug-in pro-genocide centrists here suddenly drop their support for Harris.

report