Do keep in mind proton also runs a VPN he may have been running their VPN and they complied.

The French Activist was using ProtonMail e-mail for bad usages

I don’t trust ANYONE to decide on my behalf what a “bad usage” is.

I see that as offering services that people clearly use and value, and that the bills have to be paid somehow. So as long as proton can deliver the privacy and security features it promises, I personally don’t see anything wrong with providing an alternative when the only other options are built on monetizing your data.

You set up the forwarding in google, not proton. You mark the forwarded emails in your proton mailbox. You forward the emails to your proton account until you changed all the sources that you care about from your google to your proton mailbox. Then you turn off forwarding.

Google never gets any more data from you except your protonmail address.

It’s really nice for the transition period. I personally forward my email to Tuta, which lets me slowly convert my services to my new address. I have my most important ones switched over now, but I had to switch dozens over (I would do 3-5 at a time, which was a pain).

I’ll probably leave my gmail forwarding to my Tuta account, just because there’s no way I’m going to go though every single service I have ever used and switch it over, and inevitably some contact will continue using my old email.

As far as Google goes, all it knows is that it’s getting less and less emails, and that what remains is being forwarded to <email>@tuta.com. But that’s not my main email address though, it’s just the one I set the account up with. I actually use <name>@<custom domain>, and I have a bunch of aliases configured for each type of account (e.g. <name>-banking@<custom domain> for my bank accounts, <name>-bills@<custom domain> for utilities and whatnot, etc). But that’s still not my actual, personal email, which is <name>@<different custom domain>, and I only give that one to my family and friends.

So in short:

• gmail -> tuta.com email - all Google knows about
• random online accounts -> custom domain 1
• family/friends -> custom domain 2

If I can convince my SO to switch, I’ll give them an account at custom domain 2 and tell them to only use it for personal contacts, and to have everything else go through their old gmail or a Tuta alias. If I ever decide to switch to Proton, I’d have to transition all of those custom domain 1 emails to some proton aliases (unless I pay for the higher tier), which would be a pain, especially since the main reason I use these custom domains is to make it easier to switch services (e.g. just point my DNS records to the new host).

That’s not everyone’s privacy posture. Some people use Proton to hide, some people use it to secure, some for both. If your goal is to secure, google’s antiprivacy isn’t against that.

I’m with you, though.

you might want to look at mailcow if you want to self-host your email server

It’s probably tight enough for your needs. Unless you live in Switzerland or are breaking Swiss law, they’d need a really good reason to send your data anywhere.

Unless you’re a climate activist in France:

• ProtonMail Amends Its Policy After Giving Up an Activist’s Data -(archive)-

“The email service says it was unable to appeal a Swiss court’s demand to log the IP address of a French climate advocate.”

Unless you live in Switzerland or are breaking Swiss law

That’s the thing though, governments tend to make everything illegal so they can selectively enforce.