You are viewing a single thread.
View all comments View context
9 points

This is such an ignorant statement. They’re complaining about the lack of infrastructure, not the car or tech. We need as many zero emission techs as possible, not just hoping batteries eventually figure it out.

permalink
report
parent
reply
11 points
*

A lot of hydrogen is derived from petroleum. Combine that with hydrogen’s penchant for leaking very easily and the infrastructure would require a constant replenishment of the stuff just to keep idle. Extrapolate that to hydrogen stations being as common as gas stations and you’ll see a lot of waste. For every day car use, it’d be better to use batteries.

permalink
report
parent
reply
13 points

All hydrogen is derived from petroleum.

Ftfy.

It’s absolutely possible to get hydrogen through electrolysis. There is effectively 0 being produced this way today.

Hydrogen is and has always been a way to greenwash natural gas consumption.

permalink
report
parent
reply
5 points

Hydrogen as a fuel source is terrible, regardless of the amount of infrastructure surrounding it. It leaks like literally nothing else, you need to generate it (meaning it’s essentially energy storage), and the result of the two facts mean that it’s a horribly wasteful way to propel a car. The only reasons it’s an effective rocket fuel are because NASA doesn’t need to store it long-term and the savings you get from a traditional battery are far-outweighed by the benefits of a lighter load the further along you get.

This hype around H fuel is absolutely fucking batshit.

permalink
report
parent
reply
-1 points

No it’s not, this is like complaining that EVs suck back in the day because they used lead-acid batteries… that’s what you and the rest of the anti-hydrogen groups are pissy about. It’s new tech, and has it’s place in renewables.

permalink
report
parent
reply
3 points

I think you lack important knowledge about the fundamental physical limitations of storing hydrogen.

For the record, I’m a transhumanist. New tech doesn’t scare me, and lackluster present performance isn’t something I view as a bad sign when considering the potential of researching new tech. I think you’re emotionally invested in something you personally view as the future, like solar roadways or the hyperloop. In my community, it’s seen as virtuous to be able to notice and admit when you’re wrong. I think more should do the same.

permalink
report
parent
reply
2 points

hydrogen is just a very inefficient battery for strong electrical power.

permalink
report
parent
reply

Automotive Industry

!automotive@discuss.tchncs.de

Create post

News and discussion about the automotive industry.

Community stats

  • 205

    Monthly active users

  • 200

    Posts

  • 188

    Comments

Community moderators