My phone with 2FA codes has diedā€¦ againā€¦ for the 3rd time in something over 2 years (average Poco X3 Pro experience).

Iā€™ve used the Cisco Duo app, mainly for the convenience of automatic backups. After all, this has saved me the last time my main phone died. Connect GDrive, download DB, enter passphrase to decrypt, there you go.

Iā€™ve turned on my still barely functioning 2017 Moto G5s Plus. There I had the Duo app. Upon opening it says something along the lines of ā€œDevice offline, showing on-device accounts only.ā€
How does that read to you? Auto-sync, I thought.
I connected to the internet, refreshed the app, nothing. I go to settings, check the backupā€¦ horror!
ā€œLast backup: October 6th 12:06ā€
I opened the app at 12:06.

Why would you update the backup if it has more recent timestamp than current version?
ā€œHmmā€¦ this phone last backed up in 2023, most recent backup on cloud is 2024, yep, OVERWRITE IT WITH 2023 VERSION!!ā€

Hmmā€¦ this also means Iā€™ve lost access to my Cisco NetAcad school accountā€¦

Welp, lesson learned, switching to Aegis.

Since disabling TOTP requires TOTP token, I have no way to disable it. I hope the instance admin can, but SDF has far more important shit to care about.


I am thinking on getting something crazy like Ulefone Armor 24 brick. Though it lacks things like 5G, stereo speakers, and 4K video recording, but I can afford it and have it shipped tomorrow morning.

21 points

Pro tip: if you have nextcloud you can set aegis to backup to a folder synced to the cloud, giving you automatic cloud backups. It can keep multiple copies too to prevent a situation like that happening.

But yeah, sorry that happened, hope you find another way to access those accounts.

permalink
report
reply
2 points

I do this, but with keepass (keepass on all devices and then sync with nextcloud). Saved my butt a few times, I can go into the file history and pull an old version of the keepass db out of it, and then keepass has a merge feature, so I can pull the old file out, and merge with current to find missing records.

Anywayā€¦ backups good.

permalink
report
parent
reply
16 points

This is why more sites need to support multiple 2FA devices. Most of them support a fallback like SMS, but they restrict you to one key. I canā€™t think of any reason to restrict this other than trying to ā€œkeep it simpleā€ for users, which is just silly.

permalink
report
reply

Or implement backup codes. I have backup codes for sites like Google. They are some longer single-use codes that can be used to login and reset 2FA. A lot of sites have that.

But yeah, I never thought of multiple keys. I could simply enroll and un-enroll each device. Safer and more convenient.

permalink
report
parent
reply
1 point

I think everywhere I use 2FA they also have downloadable backup codes, but you have to store those securely somewhere also.

permalink
report
parent
reply
3 points

This is why i like physical hardware keys

permalink
report
parent
reply
1 point

I yearn for a day user agents can not suck. Backups and syncing should not be this hard!

permalink
report
parent
reply
12 points
*

Sorry about that, but thank you for this post, I had no idea Lemmy finally implemented 2FA.

EDIT: On second thought, there actually is no way to generate a recovery code, so I think Iā€™ll wait a little longer.

permalink
report
reply
5 points

recovery code tip: just save the secret it gives you and then you can put it in another app

permalink
report
parent
reply
2 points

Thatā€™s actually not a bad idea, thank you!

permalink
report
parent
reply

OK, I recovered it. It seems Lemmy (at least 0.19.3) has no rate limiting for trying 2FA codes.

Edit: Fixed typo (seem -> seems)

permalink
report
parent
reply
3 points

Oh, this doesnā€™t sound very secure

permalink
report
parent
reply
6 points

Ahh i had this with a hungry shark world account. I was huge on the game, grinded insane from the start of the game so i had a ton of shit that was only available in older versions and when i moved to a new phone and wanted to restore the backup it overwrote it losing me years of data. Snorted copium for a few weeks but gave up after. Never played it since then.

permalink
report
reply
4 points
*

If you used GDrive, it might have kept the old backup but version controlled it instead of deleting it.

permalink
report
reply

Perhaps, but it seems this is a hidden portion of Drive that only the app itself can access.

permalink
report
parent
reply
2 points

Check to see if itā€™s an orphaned file. https://support.google.com/drive/thread/236647252/what-is-an-orphaned-file?hl=en What is an orphaned file? - Google Drive Community

permalink
report
parent
reply

Nope, but thanks.

It uses the hidden appDataFolder and it seems the files in it can only be accessed via those apps.
I found some more (but old) info here: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/22832104/how-can-i-see-hidden-app-data-in-google-drive

Maybe I could figure out something from those examples, but based on Google thereā€™s just mere 4KB of data. That doesnā€™t sound promising.

permalink
report
parent
reply