0 points

Because copyright is bullshit and they benefit from largely ignoring it.

permalink
report
reply
0 points

There are several things to unpack here.

First, if you think Chinese IP (not just copyright) laws are lax, come visit me and try to use the IP of a major Chinese company like, say, Huawei. Just let me keep a safe distance from you while you do it, OK?

Second, where they are “lax” is with specifically foreign IP: copyright or patent or whatever. And even there, if the foreign IP holder has significant presence in China they can come down on infringement like Huawei could. It’s just that foreign IP holders often have no such Chinese presence and are faced with an inability to fight IP infringement in China. You know, exactly like a small player in, say, Thailand being faced with her work being stolen and sold all over the USA might find. Or, even when the foreign entity has presence in the USA … well, shall we ask Samsung how they feel about US courts’ protection of their patents when Apple steals them? (Hint: it doesn’t go well if it’s a foreign company vs. an American one in an American court.)

Third, and most importantly, likely the source of a lot of trouble, is that Chinese IP law is, critically, very different from IP law in western countries. Baseline assumptions are different, for starters. If you come to China in matters that involve valuable IP and you don’t hire a lawyer intimately familiar with CHINESE IP law, you’re going to get fucked and rightly so. It’s pretty arrogant and colonial to assume that every other nation in the world must follow your rules on their own soil. (Consider how you’d react to a flip in this: a Chinese company going to your nation and expecting you to obey Chinese IP law to understand why the notion is ludicrous.)

permalink
report
reply
0 points

Haha thanks for your insights!

permalink
report
parent
reply
0 points

it doesn’t go well if it’s a foreign company vs. an American one in an American court

Do you have an example of that?

permalink
report
parent
reply
0 points

Not Chinese but I think that something like copyright law never existed in Chinese history. And they are not going to copy such a bad concept from other countries.

permalink
report
reply
0 points

“Not Chinese but here’s what I think about China anyway because I can’t listen instead of speak.”

permalink
report
parent
reply
0 points

What is wrong with their assessment? Why do you think ad hominems will make you right?

permalink
report
parent
reply
0 points

Copyright laws (and other IP laws) exist in China. Ergo “never existed in Chinese history” is false on the face of it. Q.E.D.

Duh.

permalink
report
parent
reply
0 points

Actually, Chinese copyright law got amended in June 2021 and is pretty much the same as in many other countries, now even granting financial reimbursement upon infringement. You can read the current 2021 version of IP law translated into English here: https://jimmylawyer.com/copyright-law-of-the-peoples-republic-of-china2021-version/

permalink
report
reply
0 points

Chinese copyright laws are not lax. American copyright laws are dystopian and opressive. Knowledge should be shared.

permalink
report
reply
0 points

Maybe there can be a middle ground. There’s not only two countries in the world. Shocking, right?

permalink
report
parent
reply

China, 中国

!china@lemmy.ml

Create post

English

This is a forum dedicated to China, Chinese culture Chinese language, and Chinese people.

Our Matrix chat

Rules:

  • Be civil, be respectful, don’t attack other users
  • No racism, sinophobia, or other bigotry allowed
  • No misinformation
  • Follow all other Lemmy rules

中文

这是一个专门讨论中国、中国文化、中国语言和中国人的论坛。

我们在 Matrix 的聊天室

规则:

  • 要文明,要尊重,不要攻击其他用户
  • 不允许有种族主义、仇视中国人或其他偏执行为
  • 不允许故意提供错误信息
  • 遵守 Lemmy 的所有其他规则

Related communities / 相关的互联网论坛


Community icon by CustomDesign on MYICONFINDER, licensed under CC BY-NC 3.0

Community stats

  • 173

    Monthly active users

  • 141

    Posts

  • 133

    Comments

Community moderators