Comment by roadrunner_ex@lemmy.ca on Free-threaded CPython is ready to experiment with!

I’m curious to see how this whole thing shakes out. Like, will removing the GIL be an uphill battle that everyone regrets even suggesting?Will it be so easy, we wonder why we didn’t do it years ago? Or, most likely, somewhere in the middle?

Did you read the article?

Yes, testing infrastructure is being put in place and some low-hanging fruit bugs have already been squashed. This bodes well, but it’s still early days, and I imagine not a lot of GIL-less production deployments are out there yet - where the real showstoppers will potentially live.

I’m tenatively optimistic, but threading bugs are sometimes hard to catch

The reality is just that some kind of python code will have the same race conditions as most other languages moving forward and that’s ok.

threading bugs are sometimes hard to catch

Putting it mildly! Threading bugs are probably the worst class of bugs to debug

Definitely debatable if this is worth the risk of impossible bugs. Python is very slow, and multi threading isn’t going to change that. 4x extremely slow is still extremely slow. If you care remotely about performance you need to use a different language anyway.

Python can be extremely slow, it doesn’t have to be. I recently re-wrote a stats program at work and got a ~500x speedup over the original python and a 10x speed up over the c++ rewrite of that. If you know how python works and avoid the performance foot-guns like nested loops you can often (though not always) get good performance.

you must have written some really really horrible c++

Unless the C++ code was doing something wrong there’s literally no way you can write pure Python that’s 10x faster than it. Something else is going on there. Maybe the c++ code was accidentally O(N^2) or something.

In general Python will be 10-200 times slower than C++. 50x slower is typical.

You’re thinking of CPython. PyPy can routinely compete with C and C++, particularly in allocation-heavy or pointer-heavy scenarios.

Unless the C++ code was doing something wrong there’s literally no way you can write pure Python that’s 10x faster than it. Something else is going on there.

Completely agreed, but it can be surprising just how often C++ really is written that inefficiently; I have had multiple successes in my career of rewriting C++ code in Python and making it faster in the process, but never because Python is inherently faster than C++.

Nope, if you’re working on large arrays of data you can get significant speed ups using well optimised BLAS functions that are vectorised (numpy) which beats out simply written c++ operating on each array element in turn. There’s also Numba which uses LLVM to jit compile a subset of python to get compiled performance, though I didnt go to that in this case.

You could link the BLAS libraries to c++ but its significantly more work than just importing numpy from python.

You’re both at least partly right. The only interpreted language that can compete with compiled for execution speed is Java and it has the downside of being Java.

That being said, you might be surprised at how fast you can make Python code execute, even pre-GIL changes. I certainly was. Using multiprocessing and code architected to be run massively parallel, it can be blazingly fast. It would still be blown out of the water by similarly optimized compiled code but, is worth serious consideration if you want to optimize for iterative development.

My view on such workflows would be:

Write iteration of code component in Python.
Release.
Evaluate if any functional changes are required. If so, goto 1.
Port component to compiled language, changing function calls/imports to make use of the compiled binary alongside the other interpreted components.
Release.
Refactor code to optimize for compiled language, features that compiled language enables, and/or security/bug fixes.
Release.
Evaluate if further refactor is required at this time, if so, goto 6.

Welcome to the main community in programming.dev! Feel free to post anything relating to programming here!

Cross posting is strongly encouraged in the instance. If you feel your post or another person’s post makes sense in another community cross post into it.

Hope you enjoy the instance!

Rules

Follow the programming.dev instance rules
Keep content related to programming in some way
If you’re posting long videos try to add in some form of tldr for those who don’t want to watch videos

Wormhole

Follow the wormhole through a path of communities !webdev@programming.dev

Free-threaded CPython is ready to experiment with!(labs.quansight.org)

Programming

!programming@programming.dev

Rules

Wormhole

Community stats

Community moderators