You are viewing a single thread.
View all comments View context
2 points
*

Which federal law are you referring to? EMTALA does not supersede state law, nor does it prevent the state from pursuing criminal charges for abortion.

It’s unrealistic to expect a significant number of doctors to throw away their livelihoods and go to prison to prove a legal threat. Doctors are being advised by risk management divisions of the hospital to not even consider abortions in these cases (in certain states) because it means saying goodbye to your practice, your savings, and your family.

Texas successfully challenged EMTALA's application to abortion cases through a lawsuit in 2022. The 5th Circuit Court ruled that EMTALA does not mandate abortion care or override state law. Texas became the only state exempt from federal emergency care requirements for pregnant patients. Under Texas law, abortion is only permitted for "risk of death" rather than EMTALA's broader "serious jeopardy" to health standard

Tuesday’s ruling, authored by Judge Kurt D. Engelhardt, said the court “decline[d] to expand the scope of EMTALA.”

“We agree with the district court that EMTALA does not provide an unqualified right for the pregnant mother to abort her child,” Englehardt wrote. “EMTALA does not mandate medical treatments, let alone abortion care, nor does it preempt Texas law.”

https://www.texastribune.org/2024/01/02/texas-abortion-fifth-circuit/

permalink
report
parent
reply
-1 points
Removed by mod
permalink
report
parent
reply
2 points
*

EMTALA supercedes state law because it is federal law. This is standard legal doctrine.

Texas disagrees. Please see above source.

Nobody has been prosecuted for performing an abortion since the Dobbs decision. Hundreds of abortions have happened in Missouri since Dobbs, and nobody has been prosecuted there.

No one’s going to risk their livelihood on precedent. While legal precedent is important, it doesn’t provide meaningful reassurance when the stakes are this high.

Do you have any specific examples of such cases?

permalink
report
parent
reply
-1 points
Removed by mod
permalink
report
parent
reply

Leopards Ate My Face

!leopardsatemyface@lemmy.world

Create post

Rules:

  • If you don’t already have some understanding of what this is, try reading this post. Off-topic posts will be removed.
  • Please use a high-quality source to explain why your post fits if you think it might not be common knowledge and isn’t explained within the post itself.
  • Links to articles should be high-quality sources – for example, not the Daily Mail, the New York Post, Newsweek, etc. For a rough idea, check out this list. If it’s marked in red, it probably isn’t allowed; if it’s yellow, exercise caution.
  • The mods are fallible; if you’ve been banned or had a comment removed, you’re encouraged to appeal it.
  • For accessibility reasons, an image of text must either have alt text or a transcription in the comments.
  • All Lemmy.World Terms of Service apply.

Also feel free to check out !leopardsatemyface@lemm.ee (also active).

Icon credit C. Brück on Wikimedia Commons.

Community stats

  • 2.2K

    Monthly active users

  • 79

    Posts

  • 3.1K

    Comments