You are viewing a single thread.
View all comments
141 points

I feel bad for this kid. That really is a bad warning dialog. Nowhere does it say it’s going to delete files. Anyone who thinks that’s good design needs a break.

Half the replies are basically “This should be obvious if your past five years of life experience is similar to mine, and if it isn’t then get fucked.” Just adding insult to injury.

permalink
report
reply
69 points

I’m not great at English, but “discard all changes” shouldn’t ever mean “Delete”.

permalink
report
parent
reply
30 points

In the context of version control it does. Discarding a change that creates a file means deleting the file.

permalink
report
parent
reply
15 points

If you have set up your staging area for a commit you may want to discard (unstage) changes from the staging area, as opposed to discarding changes in the working directory.

Of course, the difference between the two is obvious if you’re using git CLI, but I can easily see someone using a GUI (and that maybe isn’t too familiar with git) misunderstanding “discard” as “unstage”.

Either way, what happened here indicates that all the files were somehow added to the VC, without having been committed first, or something like that, because git will not let you discard a file that is untracked, because that wouldn’t make any sense. The fact that the GUI let this person delete a bunch of files without first committing them to the index is what makes this a terrible design choice, and also what makes the use of the word “discard” misleading.

permalink
report
parent
reply
3 points

“Discard” is not a git operation.

permalink
report
parent
reply
2 points

Ok fair enough, but I’m under the impression these files existed before the source control was implemented.

I guess it’s all up to how the program handles existing files.

permalink
report
parent
reply
5 points

I’m pretty sure vscode shows a confirmation dialog when discarding changes will permanently delete a file. I’ve done that recently with temporary files that were no longer needed.

permalink
report
parent
reply
9 points

I remember following the drama back in the day. That warning you saw was the result of this now-classic bug report.

permalink
report
parent
reply
2 points

Did you even read the thread?

permalink
report
parent
reply
3 points

the alternative to deleting is emptying the file contents, which is essentially the same…

permalink
report
parent
reply
42 points

Also, why not send them to the recycle bin? I never really thought about it before, but that does seem a reasonable UX improvement for this case

permalink
report
parent
reply
3 points

Because “the underlying Git nukes them right away, so why shouldn’t we perma-delete the files, too?”

Anything else’d be effort…

permalink
report
parent
reply
8 points

Honestly it probably just runs the underlying git command

permalink
report
parent
reply
3 points

I wonder if there’s already a git extension to automatically stash the working tree on every clean/reset/checkout operation…

permalink
report
parent
reply
4 points

Came here to say this. No one deserves this, not even new programmers who try to learn things.

Some programming tools are really powerful compared to what new users are used to. If you come from the world of Microsoft Office and Apple whatever it’s called, everything is saved automatically to cloud and there is some local backup file somewhere which you can just restore. Modern programs are designed to protect users against their own mistakes, and when suddenly that is taken away, it can be a jarring experience.

permalink
report
parent
reply
4 points

It’s so fucking infuriating that so many devs act like this. “This should’ve been obvious!” Fuck off, that’s an unhelpful statement. “You should’ve been using version control! No backup, no sympathy!” Fuck off, they were literally trying to begin using version control for backups.

Even half the comments on this very Lemmy thread are disparaging this dev. I wonder how many actually read the thread and found that there was a bug discovered causing this feature to delete files not even associated with git?

But, congratulations to them, I suppose. Congratulations on making fun of someone. I hope it makes them feel powerful. 🙄 Devs can be so toxic.

permalink
report
parent
reply
-3 points
*

If you’re going to use a git tool, you need to know how git works.

There are 0 excuses for not having months of work in a repo, none. I have no sympathy whatsoever. How the fuck do you spend so many months without backing up your project or stuffing it in a repo?

No sympathy. Dude is a shit developer and he learned an invaluable lesson.

permalink
report
parent
reply
7 points

My guess is that this is a teenager, and this is probably their first experience with git and version control in general. Just a hunch.

Anyway, it is reasonable to expect a mainstream GUI app from one of the largest companies in the world to be approachable for people who do not know all the inner workings of the command line tools that are used behind the scenes. And it is reasonable to expect any destructive action to have clear and bold warnings. “Changes will be discarded” is not clear. What changes? From the user’s perspective, the only changes were regarding version control, so “discarding” that should leave them where they started — with their files intact but not in version control.

Have mercy on the poor noobs. We were all there once.

permalink
report
parent
reply
2 points

If you’re going to use a git tool, you need to know how git works.

I guarantee you at least half of git users would get glossy eyes as soon as you mention blobs and trees, yet they all still manage to use it daily successfully.

There are 0 excuses for not having months of work in a repo, none. I have no sympathy whatsoever. How the fuck do you spend so many months without backing up your project or stuffing it in a repo?

I need you to listen to me very carefully: THEY WERE FUCKING SETTING UP A REPO WHEN THIS HAPPENED.

permalink
report
parent
reply
0 points

No, by his own admission, he was playing around with the IDE. He wasn’t interested in the version control, he was interested in the pretty editor.

I suggest you go read the original issue.

permalink
report
parent
reply

Programmer Humor

!programmer_humor@programming.dev

Create post

Welcome to Programmer Humor!

This is a place where you can post jokes, memes, humor, etc. related to programming!

For sharing awful code theres also Programming Horror.

Rules

  • Keep content in english
  • No advertisements
  • Posts must be related to programming or programmer topics

Community stats

  • 2K

    Monthly active users

  • 861

    Posts

  • 14K

    Comments